|   | |||||
| SCHOLASTIC COACH MAGAZINE ALL-AMERICANS | |||||
|   | |||||
|   | |||||
| Year | Name | High School (City) | College(s) | ||
| 1960 | Charles "Cotton" Nash | Lake Charles | Kentucky | ||
| 1964 | Don Chaney | McKinley (Baton Rouge) | Houston | ||
| 1964 | Bobby Lane | Newman (New Orleans) | Davidson | ||
| 1965 | Isiah King | St. Augustine (New Orleans) | Hiram Scott (Neb.) | ||
| 1966 | Fabien Mang | Jesuit (New Orleans) | None | ||
| 1967 | James "Poo" Welch | LaGrange (Lake Charles) | Tyler J.C. (Tex.); Houston | ||
| 1968 | Al Sanders | Baton Rouge | LSU | ||
| 1971 | Louis Dunbar | Webster (Minden) | Houston | ||
| 1972 | Edmond Lawrence | W.O. Boston (Lake Charles) | McNeese St. | ||
| 1972 | Robert Parish | Woodlawn (Shreveport) | Centenary | ||
| 1974 | Rick Robey | Brother Martin (New Orleans) | Kentucky | ||
| 1975 | Larry Wilson | Central Lafourche (Raceland) | Nicholls St. | ||
| 1977 | Orlando Woolridge | Mansfield | Notre Dame | ||
| 1978 | Micah Blunt | East Jefferson (Metairie) | Tulane | ||
| 1982 | Benoit Benjamin | Carroll (Monroe) | Creighton | ||
| 1983 | Tom Curry | Redemptorist (Baton Rouge) | Marshall | ||
| 1983 | Nikita Wilson | Leesville | LSU | ||
| 1985 | Jonathan Edwards | O.P. Walker (New Orleans) | Georgetown | ||
| 1986 | Dwayne Bryant | De La Salle (New Orleans) | Georgetown | ||
| 1986 | Fess Irvin | East Ascension (Gonzales) | LSU; James Madison | ||
| Note: All-America teams selected every year from 1956 to 1986 | |||||