Orsley won 173 games and lost only 73 during his ten years at Loyola, for a 70.3% career winning percentage.  He led Loyola to two consecutive appearances in the NAIA Tournament, including the NAIA national championship in 1945 and a fourth place finish in 1946.  He posted seasons of 25-5, 22-11, 21-3, 21-9, 14-2 and 15-5.

Loyola

1939-40

15-5

75.0%

Loyola

1940-41

15-6

71.4%

Loyola

1941-42

14-6

70.0%

Loyola

1942-43

14-2

87.5%

Loyola

1943-44

21-3

87.5%

Loyola

1944-45

25-5

83.3%

Loyola

1945-46

22-11

66.7%

Loyola

1946-47

16-9

64.0%

Loyola

1947-48

21-9

70.0%

Loyola

1948-49

10-17

37.0%

Totals

10

173-73

70.3%